Is being drunk an excuse in court reddit. People use it as an excuse.

Is being drunk an excuse in court reddit. Obviously this isn't an excuse.

Is being drunk an excuse in court reddit. The excuse for delving into being abusive, anti-social, physically violent or threatening is not acceptable. I realize that reddit is extremely biased towards drunk driving, but I never really got what the big deal was. It’s just not true. In this case, if the crime is uttering a threat (or something like that), whether you ultimately have intent to murder may be irrelevant. Likewise, many people will treat reasons as excuses. I never had a grandfather and my mom never had a dad because of these disgusting sacks of human waste. If you did shitty things, you got too drunk and can't handle your liquor. That’s making excuses. Are we talking 5 minutes of not being able to get through? 10? 20? And what was the issue? Was it a problem at her end, or at the Ambulance communication centre end? I like how drunk people use their bad behavior as a cop out while drunk. “I’m Never an excuse to cheat. To be clear, I’m not saying drunk driving should be legal, just that the laws are unnecessary. Often, people will share a reason that is not an excuse and expect it to excuse their behavior. But those drunk white girl stories about them comforting sad people or giving people random things like a leaf are definitely me. I'd try to negotiate down with the prosecutor, not using excuses but just based on making their life easier. Less serious. "Drunk and disorderly" is something they could take you in for. Point being private roads and other exceptions to dui status did cop have jurisdiction. In the scenario you mentioned, the person you are replying to is correct, being drunk does not excuse someone in court. Went to sleep at 2am. However, people believe that being drunk while committing a wrongdoing lessens your guilt, to whatever extent. No clue what the excuse was but my dad says nobody could keep a straight face, including the judge when he was brought in. Usually that means you weren't just drunk, you were being loudly drunk, meaning you were drunkenly stumbling around while singing at the top of your lungs at 1 am and throwing up on the sidewalk. Court makes a decision. Its called being a fucking adult. The lawyer makes up some story that he called the woman who was a friend to come to court with him because he was worried about getting in trouble for being so late. Same with those who text and drive. I've been drunk many times in my life, but I've never cheated on my partner, much less been violent or sexually aggressive with anyone, ever. Obviously this isn't an excuse. Reply reply Alcohol isn’t a good excuse for cheating, but also if your boyfriend was so drunk to the point of being blacked out drunk, he couldn’t have been able to give real consent. Most people want to demonize all drunk drivers because a few of them cannot handle their booze. Someone appeals. Actually the origin of these laws was surprisingly progressive for its time. for context she didnt know I was there and I didnt know she was there we (she) were having lots of communication issues the relationship was on its last legs I saw it happen and when confronted she said she was drunk and I laughed in her face and haven't seen her since no matter how you feel you cut those people out of your life met a girl recently who became a pretty good friend. you're not a different person when intoxicated, your inhibitions get lowered, if you have responsibilities in your life that aren't conducive to being intoxicated, like lets say, young children at home for ex. Your logic doesn’t go away, but people simply use being drunk as an excuse. You're being overdramatic. The funnest level of drunk for me feels kind of like when you're a kid and you're having a sleep over with your friends. If I say something extremely offensive about his daughter he will be angry with me regardless of the amount of alcohol I have drank. You better not try to sleep off being drunk in a car. Otherwise. Now I'm not so sure. The entire point of being in a relationship is trust. There was a couple times though I gave the keys to a friend because I knew I was completely shit-faced. It is not okay whether drunk or sober to make any racists comments. And I don't mean alcoholics, because obviously you're just plain addicted to that shit. Unless you’re 17-21 I’d say ok, but if you’re older than 25 and getting black out drunk even if it’s once a month is extremely concerning. Then, you have to stop repeating the behavior. Thats why those laws exist The drunk white girl I turn into is completely different than the sober one. At first. Edit: OK, I actually can see it being used as a valid excuse for really minor kind of stupid shit that occurs in a person’s life that is 100% harmless. Like unless its for medical reasons, I don't see the point of being high. No one thinks drinking excuses you from skirting responsibility. Edit: I like how a lot of people are making further arguments/excuses, to show that while drunk they behave different than sober. They’ll tell you what the relevant laws are (they can’t go into the case but usually they can discuss the law and key issues on a superficial level) and they’ll be asking jurors during voir dire if they can follow the law. I have made plenty of mistakes while drunk, and those are on me, not the booze. It's never a "valid" excuse. Sheriffs deputy here. This is a message directed to all newcomers to make you aware that r/TikTokCringe evolved long ago from only cringe-worthy content to TikToks of all kinds! The only difference is you get away with it if you're drunk - you have an excuse, you can say, it wasn't me, it was the alcohol. she was trying to get out of a relationship, but just couldnt leave him. Lower courts than that court uphold that decision. Woke up around 1am, threw up. You might make stupid decisions but at the end of the day they are your own decisions. The heck it isn't! It is unreasonable & ridiculous to expect John Q. " All while all the other patrons getting drunk in a pub are left alone. In most states being drunk in a bar or a bartender serving someone to the point they are drunk is also illegal. Commonly these days I see kids do things they should absolutely know better than to not do, and do they get disciplined, no they don't instead parents use the excuse "they are kids The judge has to be super careful about how they excuse you and can’t excuse you without a “disability neutral” reason. Honestly, if it were me, I'd go to court and not make any excuses. Woke up at 6am and went to work. I lvoe everyone when I'm drunk and I'm all about peace and harmony and physical connection (not sexual). So they need to hear a reason why your condition affects your ability to be fair. No shit being drunk isn't an excuse. " They can be drunk and answer appropriately. Most People don't get drunk then break into someone else's house No but most people have done stupid things when drunk. Nearly one piece of A4, just for me, 22 charges-eek, the most you went to court for was 2 sometimes 3. No it is not, also don’t date people that get black out drunk. Part of being an adult is being self-aware enough to know if you can handle your alcohol. My point is that people want to lump all drunk drivers together, as the whole 'lower it to . In other words, being drunk or on drugs cannot be used as an excuse in court to fight a criminal charge. The fundamental principle of criminal law is that individuals are responsible for their actions, and voluntary intoxication does not typically excuse or justify criminal conduct. Reply reply Being drunk may be an explanation and or a reason for behavior you are not proud of but it can never be an excuse. No more Being drunk makes you forget about those X reasons If you're consenting, then there shouldn't be those X reasons. It goes to a higher court. You didn’t mean it that way or would normally do that, you were just drunk and had poor judgement as a result. Again, the judge was only really concerned about injuries and wasn't really trying to catch the guy in a lie at this point, but then she starts questioning this woman who it turns Being drunk may be an explanation and or a reason for behavior you are not proud of but it can never be an excuse. So, fellow college students, drunk parents, loners, social butterflies, managers, average joes, homeless people in internet cafés, fellow followers of the alcohol: why is being drunk or even just a little tipsy such a pleasant thing for you? Not really in court but had an settlement meeting between my client and some other sleazy lowlife which he had an dispute with, regarding the sale of an pretty expensive apartment, my client brought into the building two big construction worker guys and threatened the guy to give up his case in the parking lot I watched the whole scene in disbelief and in the end it actually didn't work out The exact line between these two is unclear. This might not be valid, but people understand. It's a matter of betrayal and to what degree, to what degree you personally care about the supposed harm, value assessment of your partner, your self-worth, etc. If you have enough will power, you can easily not do bad things while drunk, same way you tell yourself sometimes that junk food is bad but you still eat it because you’re craving it. If you didn't get yourself drunk, it is a defense, and you could probably successfully win in court if you could prove that very unlikely scenario. It's an explanation, but it doesn't excuse your behavior. I'd rather drive drunk than high, that's when I tend to fuck up a little bit. But yea, it’s not an excuse Aug 23, 2019 · Alcohol really is no excuse for bad behaviour – research reveals you’re still the same person after a drink or perhaps you’ve built a reputation for being the “aggressive drunk” who Like if you're drunk and you fuck someone you regret fucking the next day, that was RAPE because you couldn't control the situation, but if you're drunk and you drive a car, then it's your fault. I think people who do stupid/bad things when they are drunk should face the consequences of their actions, but I think being drunk is a reasonable excuse/explanation for their actions to others. This isn’t to excuse cheating, but it also might be something you need to talk about more with him. Especially since the landlord used to live there. Of course both happen all the time. You are absolutely still in control of what you do. If they do and they can take care of themselves ie able to walk unassisted and have a plan to get home, then they can sign. Drunk is not an excuse there. Being drunk is not an excuse, plain and simple. Another lawyer checking in. Those are your options. Can't arrest them for being gay, so they invoke this 'drunk in a pub' law as an excuse to get the police involved. It's one thing to get too drunk and make a fool of yourself, but drunk people are still bound to the same laws, rules, and social expectations as sober ones. Drinking is something that, in every part of the world, bonds people, brings them together, removes the inhibition and antisociality that are a part of our closed-off It mentions being "given to drunkenness" which I believe is interpreted as being drunk regularly. . It seems that very drunk driving was the culprit there, combined with poor driving skills. Nov 25, 2023 · Is Being Drunk a Defence in Criminal Proceedings? In most legal jurisdictions, being intoxicated is not a valid defence in and of itself for criminal behaviour. Being drunk is not the same thing as being "altered. Most people invested in a relationship aren't going to drop it instantly to change their whole life around for some magical potential partner they And the responses generally lack nuance and include some form of “being drunk is no excuse for cheating” “you only do something drunk that you want to do sober, so your partner is a cheater at heart” “I get drunk all the time and I’ve never once cheated, so that’s not an excuse” They comments tend to cut right to the point of Regardless of being drunk or not. The reason why being drunk isn't a defense is that you got yourself drunk, so you can't use your own actions to get yourself out of a crime you committed because of those actions. People who act crazy and stupid are just using drinking as an excuse. I go to the list outside the court room which shows who's up in court. Anyhow. It’s not an excuse for saying hurtful things. You have been making excuses. Cars are lethal instruments, and it only takes one time of being drunk, being too stressed, being distracted, any reason to not pay attention to the road in order to hit and kill a pedestrian, accidentally run a red light or stop sign and hit someone, roll your vehicle and hurt yourself too much can go wrong. (or a relationship that you I've never quite understood the blanket statement of "mental illness is not an excuse for x, y, z". Some people may try and use drinking too much as an excuse but it is not an excuse. I wish I had never met my Q. This isn't about feminism or anti-feminism; this is just about stupidity. Welcome to r/TikTokCringe!. (In the real world, at least in the UK, being drunk is not a defence, because most people understand intoxication to be something that impedes their judgement and coordination, and so it will be argued that the person did not take enough care not to get drunk before wrapping their car around a lamppost/killing their wife's lover in a jealous People use it as an excuse. And you can find endless sources of creativity from being sober, like by observing the world around you, reading books, looking at art (many artists don't do drugs, so like I never got this excuse that being sober or high is required for creative thinking). They just don't know their limits. Everything is sort of a rush, everyone is laughing and having fun and being kind of loud, you're a little tired because you're up past your bed time but that's part of the fun. He can’t even remember who the person was. It is a crime because it was on a public road within cops jurisdiction. However, that guy's still dead and it's still your fault, so it isn't an excuse. But consensual sex is not a crime, in that case being drunk is putting yourself in a state of vulnerability, not giving you an excuse to do something stupid. "I ran the stop sign because I (wasn't paying attention so I) didn't see it" is an attempt at an excuse. Obviously not a rational feeling but fuck these people. So he can prove beyond a doubt guy was driving drunk, BUT that is only half the equation. It can be part of a diminished capacity defense but again it is not an excuse. And as for being arrested for walking home drunk. If you can’t act like a considerate human being when you drink, don’t drink. That's the entire point of having a court system based on precedent. Drink less, make better decisions, no need to make shitty excuses. If that doesn't work and I ended up in front of the judge, I'd be 100% contrite, say I have zero excuse, I am totally in the wrong, and I will never do that again. Being drunk makes you forget about them, so you might feel ok with trying to consent but wouldn't when sober. Then got cut off from pain meds when the clinic gave all patients a months supply and said they “no longer would prescribe long term opioids “. The only reason why I personally don’t see it as ever being a valid excuse is because you can’t really pick and choose when the “I am drunk” excuse is well and truly valid. Drinks catch up to you. So even if the judge doesn’t want to keep stopping the trial to accommodate you, they can’t say that without it being discrimination. she complained about him all the time but still is with him. This proves my point. Pouring water on people unprovoked is an a-hole move, and so is making a mess for someone else to clean. Say it in a nice way, but the whole thing needs to be said, otherwise the person is sitting at home thinking "were they being honest and i should text them in a month, or were they lying and just want me to go away". If it were a reasonable excuse people wouldn’t be prosecuted for drink driving or assault while intoxicated While being drunk can lower inhibitions and lead to poor decision-making, being blackout drunk is a whole different level. You are always responsible for your actions. 22 was definitively the record. Second (and last time) I got drunk, I was at my sisters house trying tequila for the first time. If it wasn't "PMS" it would have been something else. So, apologize and recognize that you’re a lousy drunk. Now enjoy the consequences. There is absolutely no excuse, especially in Korea where you can have someone drive your car home, taxis operate all through the night and there are buses/subways depending on the time. It does matter because you leave the door open in the other person's mind. No one actually believes this. Be honest and tell them you don't want a relationship with them. Nothing really special. if someone has an alcohol addiction, they need help, but otherwise it is fully and completely a choice and people who drink know what they’re like when they drink. Have a guy on my hall who will commonly do stupid shit like stumble into our room and fall over and throwing shit at us and getting in girls faces and sleeping on peoples beds. TL;DR: Drunk is not an excuse. Massive internal and external injuries, wasn’t expected to survive. Yeah being totally black out drunk is the only time people don't know what they're doing. No. In a perfect world I'd be saying "No, there is no excuse, you could have called an ambulance", but I'd love to see more information regarding this last bit. Take responsibility instead of making excuses that were ultimately your fault anyway. YTA. The alcohol didn’t make the choices. Loved it. The ques I will cut him slack, but "I was drunk" is never an excuse. If you're truly a good person then you'll be a good person while drunk. Being buzzed or even mildly drunk, for most people, happens without the extreme side effects. Drunk you is doing what sober you thinks about. Unless you're really really wasted, issues like hangovers and blackouts can be avoided. I have been blackout drunk before and I know that I had control over what I did. Being drunk is great excuse if it was the first time they were ever drunk (or the first time they behaved at all poorly when drunk) and they immediately resolve to never get drunk again, now that they know what they can be like when drunk, and follow through on it. Saying anything racist is hurtful regardless of whether that’s a physical pain or not. Please don't hitch your wagon to an alcoholic. You chose to drink. I’m in college and the amount of people who believe that being drunk or high is an excuse to do dumbass or asshole things is insane. After all, for Jesus's first miracle he turned water into wine, the best wine at the wedding in fact. As someone that has had a court date due to drunk behaviour (bar fight), no it’s not an excuse. If you want to fix a situation that you caused while drunk, you need to address the real reason why it happened. Oct 16, 2015 · Learn whether being voluntarily intoxicated can be used as a defense for committing a criminal offense, and difference of general intent and specific intent. The only surefire way to do that is to stop getting so drunk. Sure, in some instances, the person is just being an asshole and needs to be called out for their behaviour, but as a total blanket statement, it just does not hold up. The one by Carnaby St- off Regent St. This is a very complex area of law and standards differ from state to state. I find the word "excuse" often comes into play with power dynamics, and sometimes the people talking about it are just plain wrong. DO NOT POST REDDIT DRAMA THAT YOU ARE INVOLVED IN. Being drunk is not an excuse. I've always been very anxious and very hard on myself, and drinking took the edge off - Sexually assaulted me while drunk, continuing to force himself on me while he was drunk - Getting divorced now and losing 500k in assets None of this has stopped him or even slowed him down. It’s not an excuse for terrible actions. If you get wasted, and you do something fucked up, being drunk does not justify the fucked up act you still did it. To me it’s like driving a car and getting a flat tire because you didn’t check air pressure and blame it on the car. Legitimately I think if you are caught drunk driving or texting and driving you should lose your thumbs. In the US when you choose to become intoxicated you automatically assume any and all responsibility for the outcome of any actions you take while intoxicated. As it turns out he was not in a gang at all. I'm not a criminal lawyer, but Mens Rea means whether you intended to do the act that is the crime. Like technically if two drunk people have sex and regret it after, and neither drugged the other, the law won’t do anything about that. Drunk driving angers me so much, I lost a friend in a drunk driving accident, I nearly got hit by a drunk driver in 2019. You equate hormone levels to being drunk in this way. First time getting drunk, I just played computer games at a friend's house. I see my name 22 times. Here are some more options. This subreddit is not here to help you win your reddit fight or to bring justice to someone who said something you disagree with. Nothing can stop people from being idiots, and nothing will stop idiots from finding an excuse, no matter the gender. It really is a good excuse though. the reason being drunk is not an excuse for behavior like that is because being drunk is a choice. That's why you can't consent when drunk. Listen to the attorneys and find something small to disagree with. Supreme court makes a decision. If he didn't wanted to kiss her he would have dodged it out of reflex, clumsy, but he would've. If they excused everyone who wanted to leave they would probably need to call 3 to 4 times the amount of people to find a jury. I understand the bf being absolutely wrong what I don’t get is him being wrong for going to a party and getting drunk I mean girls go to parties and get drunk to but it’s all freedom and is NARciSstic for a guy to suggest that his gf shouldn’t go To a party . It’s not an excuse for cheating on your partner. It’s not an excuse for raping someone. The only time alcohol is a consideration is if they're drunk AND disoriented or physically unable to care for themself. For me, being drunk felt freeing. Most people who vomit had no intention of vomiting. If they do, then they don't believe in that responsibility in the first place. My problem with drunk driving laws is that driving recklessly sober should be punished just as harshly as driving recklessly while drunk, and therefore drunk driving laws are redundant and unneeded. It stems from the mid 19th century and was a result of the often homeless “town drunk” being constantly arrested. Exactly my point. If you’re planning on getting drunk only hang out with people you trust or don’t get drunk enough to be unable to control yourself. It's definately not uncommon for drunk people to mistake a house, person, object as their own. Had waaaayy too much. There is 4 of us up in court for the same thing- littering (civil matter). In the event, however, that someone is literally drugged, unbeknownst to them, and commits a criminal act due to the resulting intoxication, this involuntary intoxication can be used as a defense. If you're a wolf in sheep's clothing. Don’t just apologize and then continue to drink and repeat the behavior. You are who you are. Being drunk is really a spectrum. I'm sure that if I didn't drink that opinion would be harsher. It is often said that 'ignorance of the law isn't an excuse'. Nothing was damaged or stolen. Aka "Homophobic bar owner doesn't like gay couple drinking in pub. Just stop. Additionally being drunk is not an excuse for any bad choices made while drunk. Mine even genuinely feels like a piece of shit, and yet he can't stop. TL;DR: Cheating is cheating, being drunk is irrelevant. Intoxication is not an excuse for criminal conduct, but it may deprive an intoxicated person of the mental capacity to form the intent required by law to be convicted of certain crimes. Kids know they can get away with doing things, and they do know right from wrong. Being drunk is not an extenuating circumstance for civil or criminal liability. If you get drunk and go to work and get fired, then it's your fault. May 23, 2023 · If you get drunk and say hurtful things to people you care about, you first must take ownership of your behavior and apologize. You still did the damage. It just allows the authorities to bring the hammer down on drinking establishments for whatever reason. You said so yourself here when you stated you tried to explain your intentions. /s So ridiculous how you can get punished the same amount as some irresponsible asshole when you're trying to actually do the responsible thing. Let's get you some help for your problems. “I can’t be held accountable, I was drunk”. I drove the same way when I was sober, seriously. Your post was clearly poking at how feminism had something to do with how her actions were treated. Once in a while isn't a sin (done safely, that is). The vandal was in fact born with dwarfism hence all of his graffiti being so low against the walls. Still 100% accountable, but you making bad choices while drunk is different than making those same choices sober. That means everyone is being called 3 to 4 times more frequently. Fuck drunk drivers. That includes the people who don’t mind jury duty, the people with legitimate excuses, and the people who just don’t want to be there Being drunk is always dismissed as an excuse for doing stupid/harmful things. they know. Plus getting drunk turns up the volume, it doesn't change the channel. See full list on criminaldefenselawyer. That’s not an apology. eventually the culprit was found and he was brought into court. He cheated on you, and it was on propose. The most common rationale for this rule is that an intoxication defense can be easily simulated, thus making prosecutions too difficult. Being drunk and being blackout/vomit drunk are two different things and likely 1 or 2 shots away from each other. Eventually it goes the the supreme court. Especially if you have keys anywhere in the car. Being a kid is not an excuse for doing something, or getting away with something. But it still isn't an excuse because you drank yourself into that state. I hate the entire idea of not being in control of yourself while being drunk. If you get drunk and cause a scene at a family party, then it's your fault. Which is a highly unlikely scenario compared to a scenario where both people are drunk at a party or in their homes. The amount of times I have heard that from people and I use to use it as an excuse before and it's just not. All it does is promote trying to drive home drunk. If someone is blackout drunk, they may genuinely not remember their actions and therefore cannot be held fully accountable. However, that doesn't excuse the behavior, it just means they need to take responsibility for their I think when people mention being drunk it’s more about clarifying intent and clarifying their character. That decision is now the ultimate rule of law. There's probably little harm in a mild bit of additional laughter or loose tongue, but it's when it goes past that. 08' controversy exemplifies. Gray area comes up in court. Completely ruins trust between couples. Went to sleep around 11pm. Being drunk only affects your reflexes, balance and inhibition towards doing something you wouldn't do out of shyness. regardless of being drunk, there are things you just don't say about someone's child. Apologies should not include excuses or attempts to justify the behavior. com The basic precept of criminal law is that voluntary intoxication does not excuse criminal behavior. Your intentions are not relevant. eventually she told me about how she got a DUI one night, and she was with her boyfriend and they were both drunk and he ended up hitting her and giving her a black eye (not sure of the extent of the injury Like being thrown from the car when a drunk caused the car I was in to flip on the highway. Since they had nowhere else to go, the only place they could get drunk was in public, creating a never ending loop of arrests. He's my friend and accidents happen. You will be banned if you post screenshots of anything that can be found on Reddit from the information in the screenshot or from comments in your user history. Depends how drunk you are. That was your choice. Citizen to keep up with, know and UNDERSTAND all the laws passed at the city level.

tcoxd azyzoh jcwx vkixc vlkff kmz yag iwfovi cpqmfqi chiv